Showing posts with label obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label obama. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Morning "No"

I've been watching Morning Joe on MSNBC for a while now. Joe Scarborough, in general, is a pretty smart guy, but he continues, for whatever reason to let his partisanship get in the way of facts and logic. Over the past few weeks he has been a fan of the following line (I don't have the exact quote, but it goes something like this): "Barack Obama has the thinnest resume of anyone ever running for U.S. president. Why is his experience as a community organizer, state senator, and U.S. senator for two years anymore relevant than a mayor and a governor?" He usually says this in a condescending way, in which he tries to make the argument that sarah palin. (yes, the period is there on purpose) and Barack Obama have the same experience, so how could you favor one over the other? Leaving aside his butchering of Obama's resume (he leaves out the fact that he was editor of the Harvard Law Review, a civil rights lawyer, and a constitutional law professor at one of the most prestigious law schools in the country), the case for Obama was never about experience, it's always been about good judgment, temperament, and intellect. Of the aforementioned sarah palin his demonstrated none, and John McCain has only demonstrated the latter to varying degrees. If it were only about experience, and it is valuable to a certain extent, Obama would never have been the Democratic nominee. Of course, this argument would be too easy to make, and so no one on the show has ever put that rebuttal to Joe. Mika has tried, but she always does it in such a way that makes her look as though she's not sure of it. Just once, I would like Mika to ask, "Joe, name for me one foreign policy view that sarah palin has expressed other than, 'I love Israel'."

On another note, I'm glad Lawrence O'Donnell is there to keep things somewhat sane. A great exchange occurred this morning in which he absolutely decimated former Secretary of State Eagleburger. He allows the secretary to rant and rave about how important experience is in foriegn policy, and that we can't trust Barack the novice, and then Lawerence poses the following, pretty simple, question to him:

"Secretary, it goes without argument that a U.S. Senator has more foreign policy experience than any U.S. governor, by virtue of their jobs. If that is the case, why did you feel it was ok to support the candidacies of Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush?"

Of course the secretary had no response for this that didn't require him to completely get rid of the experience argument he had just spent 8 minutes making a case for. Very well played.

UPDATE: Video from the exchange, here.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

The Maverick Counter

John McCain's insecurity in dealing with the economy over the past two weeks has been apparent. Now, in a pretty savvy political move, he is attempting to neutralize this by calling for a suspension to his campaign, and a return to Washington to help put together a bailout plan. As transparent a gimmick as this is, I think it's a smart political move. Ezra Klein eviscerates this ploy, and rightfully so. Following up on his analysis, for better or worse the ball is now in Obama's court. My advice to the Obama campaign (as if they care), would be to reject the call for the debate cancellation, stressing the importance of a national dialogue on the economic issues, and offer to McCain that the debate be repositioned from one on foreign policy to one on the economy. This not only undercuts the McCain stunt, but allows Obama an opening to reposition the debate to a terrain that he is more comfortable on than McCain.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Obama, McCain, and Bush on the Bailout

One of the central narratives of the general election campaign has been McCain's weakness on economic issues. In the wake of the banking crisis that came to a head last week, it's been interesting to watch the reactions of Obama, McCain, and Bush. Bush has been largely quiet on the issue, appearing for two minutes before the press to make a statement and took no questions. You would hope to hear a bit more from your nation's leader on this issue, but the silence is somewhat understandable, in the same way that Obama has largely resisted making specific declarative statements about what should and should not be done at this point. I expect him and Bush to refine their positions in the coming weeks, and I have no problem with that. This financial crisis is a huge mess, and there are alot of very smart people trying to figure out what should be done. As much as we would like to think that our presidents are economic wizards, they are not, which is why they surround themselves with people who are. However, what you do want from your president is someone who can digest the economic advice given to them. I suspect Bush and Obama are both trying to come up to speed on what is a very complex issue, by listening to their advisers and attempting to digest and synthesize what they're hearing. Some things are like that. Not everything can be, and should be, handled off the cuff.

McCain's response was the most interesting. His bluster on what should be done with the bailout, reinforced his insecurity on the economy. Knowing that this would be a big test for both him and Obama, McCain thought it was best to try to get out in front of the issue, which caused him to reverse himself several times within a 5 day period, recklessly call for the removal of the chairman of the SEC, and then propose a "commission" to find out what went wrong. This is not what a president does, as ABC's panel noted on This Week, but it is what John McCain does. For anyone who has been paying attention to his career this should not be a surprise. Much like president Bush in the past, McCain is attempting to mask his incompetency with his confidence. That's not the type of decision-making we need to handle the most pressing issues of the day.